Blogs and Twitter Make the Grammys—and Chris Brown—the No. 1 Topic
PEJ New Media Index February 13-17, 2012
The 54th annual Grammy Awards captured the attention of bloggers and Twitter users from February 13-17, making it the No. 1 subject on both social media platforms, according to the New Media Index from the Pew Research Center’s Project for Excellence in Journalism.
Not only did that represent one of the unusual occasions when the same topic led both social media platforms, bloggers and tweeters also focused on the same element of the story-the honoring of singer Chris Brown. Although pop icon Whitney Houston died the night before the Grammy event, the conversation largely centered on Brown, the winner for best R&B album of the year who drew notoriety after a domestic violence incident three years earlier.
Houston’s death, however, did generate three of the five most popular YouTube news videos last week.
Last week offered another example of just how potent a topic popular culture is in social media-particularly on Twitter. But this was not simply a case of bloggers and tweeters engaged in hero worship or embracing a popular entertainer. Instead it triggered commentary on the issue of domestic abuse.
And there was something of a divide in the reactions to Brown’s triumphant return to the limelight at the February 12 Grammys. Some admirers who enjoyed his performance shrugged off his history of domestic abuse. But most of the reactions condemned Brown, the Grammy Awards for honoring him, and the fans that seemed to downplay his domestic violence history. Brown himself added fuel to the fire by responding to his critics on Twitter.
No Love for Chris Brown (Or His Admirers)
Some of the stories that were popular among bloggers tackled the standard Grammy subjects. The AOL Music blog posted a photo spread of music stars on the red carpet. Bellasugar.com also focused on Grammy style (“Lady Gaga wouldn’t let her fans down on a night like the Grammys, and her hair and makeup were just as avant-garde as you’d expect”). MTV.com posted a summary of the winners of major music categories, such as record and song of the year.
But one story that lit up the blogosphere was a list compiled by BuzzFeed.com of “25 extremely upsetting reactions to Chris Brown at the Grammys.” It consisted of culled Twitter reactions to the music star that referenced his 2009 domestic violence arrest after an altercation with his girlfriend at the time, Robyn Rihanna (known as Rihanna), also a popular recording artist. The tweets compiled by BuzzFeed came from users who were pleased by Brown’s performances at the awards ceremony. “I’d let Chris Brown beat me up,” wrote one. “chris brown could beat me all he wants, he is flawless,” wrote another.
Popular blogs linked to the list and condemned the tweets.
Opinion L.A., a Los Angeles Times blog, linked to the list and criticized Brown for not taking his moment in the spotlight to speak out against domestic violence.
“Brown could have dedicated some of his time in the spotlight to a PSA so that young women, such as the ones listed above, would better understand that there’s nothing ‘hot’ about domestic violence. But he didn’t, leaving critics to rightly take him and the Grammys to task.”
Gawker weighted in with a Feb. 13 post, stating that the women who viewed Chris Brown’s Grammy performances must have “decided that his sexiness trumped his wretchedness.”
Amateur bloggers had their say, too.
Seastarr08, in a blog called “A Change of Scenery,” wrote that the compilation of Twitter posts was “truly one of the most disturbing things I’ve seen. Possibly ever.”
Some bloggers were more angry at the Grammys and Brown, such as sassyeditrix of One Unique Token: “This year’s gathering was particularly abhorrent, however, because of the Recording Academy‘s two-armed embrace of notorious enfant terrible Chris Brown. And by “enfant terrible,” I mean “sentenced domestic abuser.’”
In a rare digression, one blogger writing for Daily Motion acknowledged that the Twitter users in BuzzFeed’s list may have been writing with tongue in cheek, but still expressed disapproval: “I get that their joking, but to joke about such a sensitive topic like domestic abuse? That’s unacceptable.”*
Those on Twitter reacting to the matter of Chris Brown were no more amused than were bloggers. User jimsterling (Jim Sterling) tweeted: “Milli Vanilli lip sync’d and became industry pariahs. Chris Brown smashed a woman’s face up and won an award. America.”
Brown himself entered the fray with an answer to his critics. His tweet, from February 14, read in part: “HATE ALL U WANT BECUZ I GOT A GRAMMY.” It was later deleted, but not before being noticed, captured and spread widely.
To Brown’s tweet, droidguy1119 (Tyler Foster) had this to say: “Yes, Chris Brown. I am a “hater.” As in, I hate that you punch women and still get to walk around, rich and without a care in the world.”
The Rest of the Week’s News on Blogs
Other popular topics on blogs last week were heavily tech-oriented.
The No. 2 subject focused on privacy concerns related to the latest iPhone version after it came to light that many popular applications collect names, email addresses and phone numbers from a user’s address book, often without asking permission.
At No. 3 was the subject of Google, with many bloggers linking to a story evaluating the pros and cons of the Google+ platform.
The Nos. 4 and 5 topics revolved around APIs (application programming interfaces) and HTC Corp., a Taiwanese phone maker that is working on a set of new mobile devices that it hopes will revive its flagging fortunes.
The Rest of the Week’s News on Twitter
On Twitter, the most popular subjects other than the Grammys also focused on celebrity and pop culture.
Tied for No. 1 along with the Grammy awards were two conversations, one about how to treat a woman nicely, and another about people’s pet peeves.
Two popular celebrities-Justin Bieber at No. 2 and Will Smith at No. 3-also made the rounds on Twitter. In Bieber’s case, a video of him promoting a new singer circulated, and Smith got attention for a joke he posted on Twitter.
The No. 4 subject was Zynga, a social network gaming company that launched a new game for Facebook during the week.
While bloggers and tweeters focused on Chris Brown, singer Whitney Houston’s sudden death at the Beverly Hilton Hotel on February 11 at the age of 48 dominated YouTube last week.
The No. 2 video, shot from a cell phone, captured Houston’s last public performance at R&B singer Kelly Price’s pre-Grammy party before her untimely death. The singer performed “Jesus Loves Me” with Price at Tru Hollywood on February 9 in Hollywood, California.
The No. 3 video showed MSNBC Paige Hopkins anchoring the live coverage about the death of Houston, a news story broken by the Associated Press. Entertainment reporter Courtney Hazlett gave additional information about the singer’s career and personal life over the phone.
The No. 5 video showed ABC News anchor David Muir reporting Houston’s death with a quick overview of her career that included her interview with Diane Sawyer in 2002, and a phone conversation with Chris Connelly about the singer’s career and struggle with drugs.
Most Viewed News & Politics Videos on YouTube
For the Week of February 11 – 17, 2011
|1. A digitally altered 50-second Russian-language video clip showing Prime Minister Vladimir Putin on trial for corruption and terrorism using news footage from the 2010 trial of businessman Mikhail Khodorkovsky|
|2. A footage showing Whitney Houston’s last performance at Kelly Price’s pre-Grammy party on February 9 in Hollywood, California|
|3. A video from MSNBC showing news anchor Paige Hopkins breaking the news about Houston’s death (the video has been removed by the user)|
|4. A Russian-language video clip with Russian-title ‘Terminator E-2012- our candidate’ using footage from 1991 movie ‘Terminator 2: Judgment Day’|
|5. A video from ABC News with David Muir announcing the death of singer Whitney Houston|
About the New Media Index
The New Media Index is a weekly report that captures the news agenda of social media, with a focus on blogs, Twitter and YouTube. These platforms are an important part of today’s news information narrative and shape the way Americans interact with the news. The expansion of blogs and other social media sites has allowed news-consumers and others outside the mainstream press to have more of a role in agenda setting, dissemination and interpretation. Through this New Media Index PEJ aims to find out what subjects in the national news the online sites focus on, and how that compares with the narrative in the traditional press.
A detailed description of the NMI methodology, which was recently modified in August 2011, is available here.
*For the sake of authenticity, PEJ has a policy of not correcting misspellings or grammatical errors that appear in direct quotes from online postings.